A persistent dilemma: unity or ideology?
The debate about prioritizing left-wing policies and pro-independence unity is not a recent phenomenon. However, it has now regained relevance due to an article by politician Xavier Domènech published in El Crític.
Domènech: a bridge between two realities
Xavier Domènech, former general coordinator of Catalonia in Comú, played a key role in the connection between the Comuns and the CUP. Given the current situation on the left, Domènech proposes the need for a strong alliance between ERC, Comuns and the CUP to confront the hegemony of the PSC and Junts.
Answers from Poble Lliure
In response to Domènech’s article, members of Poble Lliure, the pro-independence branch of the CUP, have expressed their opinions. Historically, Poble Lliure has maintained a position in favor of an alliance with Junts, to the detriment of the Comuns.
Constructive criticism
The representatives of Poble Lliure point out that their criticism of Domènech is constructive. They recognize the diagnosis he makes about the social reality of Catalonia, but emphasize that the new block of popular classes must also include sectors of the petty bourgeoisie.
A new social panorama
Poble Lliure argues that the new class alliance represents a response to the expulsion of various sectors by the Spanish centralist system. They recall the events of October 3, 2017, considering this bloc as the majority at present.
Ideological differences
Poble Lliure members criticize what they consider a ‘reactionary approach’ of the Comuns leadership and reject the idea of an autonomic left seeking to reform Spain. They defend a more ambitious project, centered on the ‘republic of the social majority’.
An endless debate
Domènech expressed his disappointment with ERC’s decision to form a government with Junts in 2021, which, according to him, has contributed to the current crisis of the left. Nevertheless, he maintains an optimistic message, betting on the reconstruction of a progressive alliance in the future.
This discussion about the direction that the Catalan left should take, which has intensified with the independence process, remains relevant today, as solutions are sought to overcome the current crisis.